Millions of people could lose health insurance coverage when the COVID-19 emergency ends
Federal aid to states to boost Medicaid rolls during pandemic is set to end April 16 — unless another extension is approved
Adam Sparks earns $13 an hour as an assistant manager at a movie theater in a suburb of Des Moines, Iowa. It’s enough for the 24-year-old to pay for most necessities – except health care.
He relies on Medicaid to cover medications for allergies, his recently diagnosed attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder and doctor visits and therapy sessions. He and millions of other Americans could soon face a dilemma.
Modest raises at his part-time job put him over the threshold to qualify for the government health insurance program for low-income residents. He's remained on Medicaid only because the federal government provided robust federal aid to states on the condition that they would not remove people from Medicaid until the COVID-19 public health emergency ends.
What Congress and public health experts initially viewed as a temporary measure to maintain health coverage during a once-a-century pandemic has dragged on for more than two years as Medicaid sign-ups ballooned to 78.9 million as of November, the most recent figure available.
The public health emergency is set to expire April 16. An Urban Institute report estimated up to 12.9 million Americans could lose Medicaid if the public health emergency is not extended.
The end of the emergency would ripple across other pockets of the health care industry. Federal agencies created temporary initiatives to subsidize private health insurance, improve access to telehealth, provide additional funding to hospitals and make it easier for companies that make medical devices, tests and treatments to bring their products to the market under emergency use.
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Secretary Xavier Becerra has not announced a decision on whether to extend the public health emergency, though there is reason to believe he will. HHS has extended the emergency every 90 days, and an HHS official said the agency would notify states 60 days before ending the emergency. With barely two weeks before the next deadline, that notification has not happened.
Whenever the health emergency ends, unwinding these programs will create a massive logistical task for the Biden administration. Nowhere is the potential disruption more evident than for the millions who might lose Medicaid coverage.
Sparks said his coverage helped him take care of his medical needs while trying to improve his prospects. His long-term goal is to work on film editing, a craft he's learning. He'd like to land a position editing video with a television news station, but he worries losing health insurance is an obstacle to pursuing his career.
"I don't make very much money, and I'm struggling to improve my situation as much as I can," he said. "This definitely doesn't help me. It causes major stress and anxiety."
States form plans, grapple with enormous task ahead
When the emergency ends, state Medicaid agencies will have 12 months to check the eligibility of every person and notify those who no longer qualify. This massive task is unlike anything state Medicaid programs have tackled at once, experts said.
“It's definitely the No. 1 issue on our members' priority list,” said Jack Rollins, director of federal policy for the National Association of Medicaid Directors.
Rollins said it typically takes two to three months to complete an eligibility check, and many states are preparing by verifying mailing addresses and checking cell numbers of members to ensure they have correct contact information.
It’s a monumental task for states, many of which have fewer workers to handle these checks than at the beginning of the pandemic. Some states cut back staffing, and others need to hire workers or use contractors to replace those who retired or quit.
A Kaiser Family Foundation survey released in March found 27 states have a plan on how to tackle the challenge of resuming eligibility checks. The survey found 11 states would first target enrollees who appeared to be no longer eligible; nine states plan to wait until the individual's annual renewal is due.
Iowa’s Medicaid agency continued monthly eligibility checks during the pandemic and does not anticipate major problems when the emergency ends, according to Department of Human Services spokesman Alex Carfrae.
The agency will work with navigators to help people dropped from Medicaid to find other insurance options, including the Affordable Care Act marketplace or Medicare.
After his most recent pay increase, Sparks called Iowa’s Medicaid agency because he did not want to run afoul of program rules. An Iowa Department of Human Services representative told him he might no longer qualify but would not be immediately removed, Sparks said.
“I'm just trying to be responsible,” Sparks said. “Now it feels like it’s almost a punishment because they're telling me that I'll potentially lose my insurance.”
Politics of Medicaid could be a factor
Some states could be motivated to accelerate checks because of political opposition to Medicaid expansion or because the federal government will halt extra matching funding three months after the end of the emergency. That would leave states paying a larger portion for each Medicaid enrollee, potentially squeezing budgets.
"They figure if they could drop their caseload faster, then they will save money," said Leighton Ku, a George Washington University professor and director of the center for health policy research at the Milken Institute School of Public Health.
States that look to quickly shed Medicaid enrollees may hurt their economy in the long run, an analysis co-written by Ku found.
States could save $3 billion for their share of the Medicaid bill if they remove ineligible people in six months instead of 12 months, the analysis said. By leaving so many residents uninsured, states could lose more than a half million jobs and $54 billion in economic output.
For states that maintain coverage longer, "more money ends up flowing into the state and helps make sure that hospitals and doctor's offices have money to pay for their staff," Ku said.
Some analysts are worried states that hasten the Medicaid unwinding could make mistakes and remove people who are eligible.
The Urban Institute warned the large volume of eligibility checks raises concerns that people could be incorrectly kicked off the rolls. Another risk: People who become uninsured might not be aware they could qualify for other programs. Some families might be eligible for the Children's Health Insurance Program or subsidized coverage through the Affordable Care Act marketplace, said Matthew Buettgens, an Urban Institute senior fellow.
The federal government has encouraged states to coordinate with community organizations to educate people who might lose coverage, but it's not a requirement. "Different states are likely to do different things," Buettgens said.
In Florida, community groups said the state has said little about how quickly it plans to disenroll beneficiaries.
Many residents on Medicaid have been confused about how the pandemic has allowed them to maintain coverage and could be surprised when eligibility checks resume, said Jodi Ray, director of Florida Covering Kids & Families, a University of South Florida organization that works with state agencies and community stakeholders to ensure residents have access to health insurance.
"When folks are looking for help and they cannot get through to talk to somebody, they're going to look to on-the-ground folks that know how to navigate these programs," Ray said. "We want to make sure people don’t fall through the cracks.”
Ken Alltucker is on Twitter at @kalltucker, or can be emailed at firstname.lastname@example.org