Rebels Inside The Bank Of England Are Fighting Mark Carney's Low Interest Rate Regime
There was a 7-2 split in favor of not raising interest rates at the latest Bank of England Monetary Policy Committee, the central bank has reported.
That's a bigger split than expected. Analysts expected an 8-1 split in favor of keeping rates at their current low level, according to The Guardian.
The split is the first to appear in the BofE since 2011, The Guardian added.
The minutes of the BofE's latest MPC meeting seem to be hinting that the dissenters believe the majority of directors are keeping the rate at 0.5% because they are terrified of what the markets will do the first time the rate goes up, even by only 0.25%:
These members further noted that, while there were always likely to be risks associated with the possible financial market reaction to the first increase in Bank Rate after such a protracted period, it was unclear that these risks would be lessened, and indeed possible they would be augmented, by delaying that increase.
The FT expects the split — which presages the view that an interest rate hike is coming sooner rather than later — will "jolt" the markets. Zero-interest rates are coming to an end, in other words.
The two most hawkish members voted for the rate rise. They are Martin Weale, a director of the National Institute of Economic and Social Research and lecturer in economics at the University of Cambridge; and Ian McCafferty, who had been chief economic adviser to the CBI.
Here is the BofE's summary of why they wanted interest rates to go up:
For two members , in particular, economic circumstances were sufficient to justify an immediate rise in Bank Rate. These members noted that the continuing rapid fall in unemployment alongside survey evidence of tightening in the labour market created a prospect that wage growth would pick up. They noted that it was possible that wages were lagging developments in the labour market to some extent. If that were true, wages might not start to rise until spare capacity in the labour market were fully used up. Since monetary policy, too, could be expected to operate only with a lag, it was desirable to anticipate labour market pressures by raising Bank Rate in advance of them. Moreover, if recent robust GDP growth rates had been underpinned by stimulatory monetary policy, in addition to a release of pent - up demand driven by reduced uncertainty and improved credit conditions , then the erosion of spare capacity would be likely to remain rapid while policy remained expansionary . In the judgement of these members, even after a rise of 25 basis points in Bank Rate, monetary policy would remain extremely supportive, and an early rise would facilitate the Committee’s aspiration that the rises in Bank Rate should be only gradual. These members further noted that, while there were always likely to be risks associated with the possible financial market reaction to the first increase in Bank Rate after such a protracted period, it was unclear that these risks would be lessened, and indeed possible they would be augmented, by delaying that increase.
Here's a great chart from BNP Paribas showing the hawk-dove spectrum on the MPC:
People will now watch Andy Haldane and Ben Broadbent very closely, to see if their votes follow those of Weale and McCafferty, according to The Telegraph:
Jeremy Cook, of currency firm World First, suggested that there would be "standing room only" at the speeches of Andrew Haldane and Ben Broadbent, two MPC members who might join the rebellion next.
The bank saw a mixed set of economic signals prior to the meeting. U.S. GDP was up 1%, but there was some contraction in the weaker European areas. There was a sharp fall in industrial orders in Germany, for instance.
The MPC saw a surprise uptick in consumer price inflation:
Twelve - month CPI inflation had risen from 1.5% in May to 1.9% in June, rather stronger than Bank staff and other economists had expected immediately beforehand. Most of the surprise was centred in the prices of clothing and footwear, which had risen between May and June for the first time since the CPI series had begun in 1996 . Although it was possible that this partly reflected an unusual delay to the start of the summer sales that normally caused the sub - index to fall in June — a factor which would unwind in subsequent months — there was little firm evidence to suggest that this had occurred. And there were other reasons to suppose that the increase in prices might be more lasting.
Here is the brief statement summarizing the BofE's thinking:
Minutes of the Monetary Policy Committee Meeting held on 6 and 7 August 2014
20 August 2014
?The Governor invited the Committee to vote on the propositions that:
Bank Rate should be maintained at 0.5%;
The Bank of England should maintain the stock of purchased assets financed by the
issuance of central bank reserves at £375 billion.
Regarding Bank Rate, seven members of the Committee (the Governor, Ben Broadbent, Jon Cunliffe, Nemat Shafik, Kristin Forbes, Andrew Haldane and David Miles) voted in favour of the proposition.
Ian McCafferty and Martin Weale voted against the proposition, preferring to increase Bank Rate by 25 basis points.
Regarding the stock of purchased assets, the Committee voted unanimously in favour of the proposition.
- The 10 Most Important Things In The World Right Now
- The 10 Most Important Things In The World Right Now
- Bank Of England Warns: Interest Rate 'Will Need To Start To Rise' To Fight Inflation